Part 18 of 20 · EquationsSee the whole course
How to find the break-even point (which plan is cheaper)
Write each cost as a line and find where the lines cross. That crossing is the break-even point: the amount where both plans cost the same. Below it one plan is cheaper, above it the other is.
Write each plan as a line
A plan usually has a starting price and a price per unit. The per-unit price is the slope m. The starting price is b. Suppose, with x as the gigabytes (GB) used:
Plan A: 10 to start, plus 1 per GB, so y = x + 10
Plan B: 4 to start, plus 3 per GB, so y = 3x + 4
Find the break-even point
Both plans cost the same when the two right-hand sides are equal:
x + 10 = 3x + 4
6 = 2x
x = 3 GB
Cost: 3 + 10 = 13, and 3(3) + 4 = 13 ✓
The break-even point is (3, 13): at 3 GB both plans cost 13. Move the slider below and watch the cheaper plan change at exactly that point.
Plan B: 4 + 3x
- A: 10 + 1(2) = 12
- B: 4 + 3(2) = 10
Which plan is cheaper?
Do not guess from the starting prices. Try a number on each side of the break-even:
At 2 GB: A = 2 + 10 = 12 and B = 3(2) + 4 = 10, so B is cheaper.
At 4 GB: A = 4 + 10 = 14 and B = 3(4) + 4 = 16, so A is cheaper.
So B is cheaper for less than 3 GB, and A is cheaper for more than 3 GB. The plan with the lower starting price wins at first. The plan with the lower rate per GB wins in the long run.
A second example
Plan A is 15 + 2x and plan B is 5 + 4x. Set them equal: 15 + 2x = 5 + 4x, so 10 = 2x and x = 5 GB. The cost there is 15 + 2(5) = 25. Switch the figure to this pair to see it.
Watch it explained in under a minute
The five mistakes to avoid
- Comparing only the starting prices. The cheaper-to-start plan stops being cheaper once you use enough.
- Giving the cost when the question asks for the amount. The break-even has two numbers: 3 GB and a cost of 13.
- Mixing up which side is which. Test a number on each side of the crossing.
- Assuming the plans always cross. Two plans with the same price per GB are parallel and never break even.
- Leaving out the units. Say “3 GB” and “13”, not just 3.
Try it yourself
Tap a question to see the answer.
1. Gym X costs 30 to join and 5 per visit. Gym Y has no joining fee and costs 10 per visit. When do they cost the same?
30 + 5x = 10x, so 30 = 5x and x = 6 visits. Both cost 60. Y is cheaper before 6 visits, X after.
2. Plan A is 20 + 2x and plan B is 8 + 5x. Where do they break even?
20 + 2x = 8 + 5x, so 12 = 3x and x = 4. The cost is 20 + 2(4) = 28.
3. Taxi P charges 2 + 3 per km. Taxi Q charges 5 + 2 per km. For which trips is P cheaper?
2 + 3x = 5 + 2x gives x = 3 km (both cost 11). Try 1 km: P = 5 and Q = 7, so P is cheaper for trips shorter than 3 km.
Where this fits in
“Cheaper than” is really an inequality, which is where this course goes next. Start with how to solve a linear inequality.